Keywords
graduate writing, double-blind peer feedback, experiential learning, academic writing
Abstract
While having students participate in peer feedback may be common, using an experiential learning framework to implement double-blind peer feedback practices in graduate writing is not. Using Kolb and Kolb’s (2017, 2018) experiential learning cycle as the theoretical framework, the current study explored graduate student perceptions regarding double-blind peer reviews and what worked and what did not about such peer review practices. Six master’s in education (MEd) students participated in peer feedback and revision activities—managed through the Open Journal Systems (OJS)—as a way to engage in experiential learning of a double-blind peer review process akin to that of scholarly publication. Qualitative data consisting of semi-structured interviews with participants, students’ written artifacts, and surveys were analyzed inductively to identify recurring themes. Results show that participating students had favorable perceptions of engaging in experiential learning through double-blind peer review practices. Based on the information participants provided about what worked and what did not, suggestions for further improvement of peer review practices were identified. These improvements include giving students more time, providing additional guidance, and incorporating multiple perspectives and diverse audiences into feedback practices. Based on the findings, we discuss implications for graduate writing instructional practices.
Recommended Citation
Bhowmik, Subrata and Zohbie, Aicha
(2026)
"Examining Student Perceptions of Double-Blind Peer Feedback in Graduate Writing,"
Journal of Response to Writing: Vol. 12:
Iss.
2, Article 2.
Available at:
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/journalrw/vol12/iss2/2
Included in
Arts and Humanities Commons, Language and Literacy Education Commons, Scholarship of Teaching and Learning Commons