Keywords
feedback, graduate writing, multilingual writing, international students, response to writing, writing in STEM
Abstract
While feedback on writing can play a large role in socializing graduate students into their academic communities, feedback may also strongly impact these students’ affect, motivation, and identity. To shed light on the effects of feedback over time, this longitudinal study explored 12 multilingual, international graduate STEM students’ (MIGS) reactions to the writing feedback they received on a quarterly basis throughout their first year of study. Through inductive qualitative analysis of text-based interviews and questionnaire responses, we found that students’ responses to feedback were varied and contextual; however, students largely responded positively and felt that feedback enhanced their scholarly identity and motivation to continue in their program. Students who received more feedback on writing of importance to their disciplines during the year showed more productive and critical responses to feedback over time, leading to differing impacts on affect and identity.
Recommended Citation
Minnillo, Sophia and Ferris, Dana
(2026)
"The Feedback Experiences of Multilingual, International STEM Students during Their First Year of Graduate School,"
Journal of Response to Writing: Vol. 12:
Iss.
2, Article 1.
Available at:
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/journalrw/vol12/iss2/1