Keywords

audit committee, audit partner, engagement partner, financial reporting quality, political ideology

Abstract

This study examines whether the ideological orientation of the audit partner and audit committee members— defined as their personal belief systems and inclinations, including their attitude toward risk, ambiguity, and novelty—has an impact on engagement partner selection and the effectiveness of oversight in the financial reporting process. Drawing on prior evidence that the two main US political parties reflect different ideologies, we hand-collect political donation data to construct ideological scores for audit partners and audit committee members. Our findings highlight several intriguing relationships. First, audit committees are more likely to select an ideologically dissimilar partner. Second, greater ideological dissimilarity between these two key monitors is associated with higher financial reporting quality. The effects of financial reporting quality are most pronounced among more effective audit committees and when audit partners have longer tenure with the client. These effects are incremental to both social connections between the audit partner and audit committee and to ideological differences between these parties and the CEO and CFO. Overall, the results support the notion that ideological dissimilarity between audit partners and audit committees can foster effective oversight of the financial reporting process. Moreover, ideological dissimilarity appears to be a useful and rational cue in audit partner selection decisions.

Original Publication Citation

“Do audit partner and audit committee member ideologies influence engagement partner selection and financial reporting oversight effectiveness?” with Robert Felix, Sattar Mansi, and Mikhail Pevzner. Contemporary Accounting Research.

Document Type

Peer-Reviewed Article

Publication Date

2026

Publisher

Contemporary Accounting Research

Language

English

College

Marriott School of Business

Department

Accountancy

University Standing at Time of Publication

Full Professor

Download

Included in

Accounting Commons

Share

COinS