Picornaviruses are responsible for some of the most common and debilitating diseases affecting humans and animals worldwide. The objectives of this dissertation research were (1) estimate phylogenetic relationships among 11 picornavirus genera and within three species: foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV: Aphthovirus) which afflicts cloven-hoofed animals and human rhinovirus A and B (HRV: Enterovirus) which cause the common cold; (2) better understand the impact recombination has on genomic organization and evolution; (3) characterize where positive and purifying selection has occurred in proteins and how selection has influenced phenotype. The dissertation includes four studies. The first chapter provides an overview of the evolutionary significance of recombination, its detection and estimation, and its effect on phylogenetic analysis in four biological systems: bacteria, viruses, mitochondria, and the human genome. Chapter two investigates the inter- and intra-serotypic relationships within FMDV by examining 12 genes. Gene sequences were analyzed to assess recombination breakpoint locations, genetic diversity, and natural selection in FMDV. Recombination breakpoints were located throughout the genome. Paraphyletic relationships among serotypes were not as prevalent as previously reported, suggesting that convergent evolution was prevalent. Purifying selection was the dominant evolutionary force influencing both genotype and phenotype. Chapter three examines inter- and intra-specific relationships of HRV using 11 genes. Similar hypotheses were tested as in chapter two. No recombination was detected and phylogenetic relationships among enteroviruses, HRV-A, and HRV-B remain unresolved. The evolution of HRV-A major serotypes appeared to be under extensive purifying selection, HRV-A minor serotypes under predominantly positive selection, and a nearly equal influence from both kinds of selection was evident for HRV-B serotypes. Chapter four examines phylogenetic relationships among genera using three conserved genes. The hypothesis of cospeciation between picornaviruses and their hosts was also tested. The deepest split in the family separated Hepatovirus, ‘Tremovirus’, Parechovirus, and seal picornavirus type 1 from the remainder of the family. Enterovirus and ‘Sapelovirus’ were sister taxa. Cardiovirus, ‘Senecavirus’, Aphthovirus, Erbovirus, Teschovirus, and Kobuvirus were derived from a common ancestor with Kobuvirus occupying a basal position relative to the other genera in this clade. My analyses suggest that picornaviruses have not cospeciated with their known hosts.
College and Department
Life Sciences; Microbiology and Molecular Biology
BYU ScholarsArchive Citation
Lewis-Rogers, Nicole Noel, "Evolution of Picornaviruses: Impacts of Recombination and Selection" (2008). Theses and Dissertations. 1956.
picornavirus, foot-and-mouth disease virus, human rhinovirus, molecular evolution, selection, recombination