Keywords
philosophy of action, passion, Humean theory of motivation
Abstract
It is a challenge to write a book on a topic that has received extensive treatment in philosophical discourse—especially when said treatment has been varied in purpose, angle, and aim. Hume’s work on the relationship between passion and action is one such topic. Scholarship on this theme has ranged from historically situated interpretive work, to theoretical work that assumes a Kantian foil, to the robust discourse of contemporary Humean views (which themselves vary widely in their resemblance to the historical Hume). In her book, Hume, Passion, and Action, Elizabeth Radcliffe has taken on the complex task of writing on motivation in Hume with many of these perspectives in her sights, and it has resulted in a book that clearly and helpfully walks us through the complexities and interrelations of these discourses, while simultaneously making a case for her own interpretive take on Hume’s theory of motivation. Such a labor is not for the faint of heart, and Radcliffe does an exceptional job of carefully and systematically presenting the various discussions. But the real pay-off comes as one engages Radcliffe’s own arguments. She provides the reader with several important innovations in approaching the topic of Humean motivation, including a new defense of Hume’s commitment to the motivational impotence of belief and a careful analysis of what Hume requires for the motivational efficacy of a passion. Radcliffe’s interpretive arguments will surely advance the discourse on Hume’s account of passion and action. Given their presentation alongside an incredibly helpful overview of the relevant debates, this text should be treated as essential reading to anyone looking to further contribute to these discussions.
Original Publication Citation
Paxman, K. (2018). [Review of the book Hume, Passion, and Action, by Elizabeth Radcliffe]. Hume Studies.
BYU ScholarsArchive Citation
Paxman, Katharina, "[Review of the book Hume, Passion, and Action, by Elizabeth Radcliffe" (2018). Faculty Publications. 10205.
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/facpub/10205
Document Type
Other
Publication Date
2018
Publisher
Hume Studies
Language
English
College
Humanities
Department
Philosophy
Copyright Use Information
https://lib.byu.edu/about/copyright/