Recent evidence suggests that heat, a major byproduct of exercise, may be the mediator for many vascular adaptations that come from exercise. Thus, heat therapy that increases muscle temperature in a comparable way to exercise may be an advantageous alternative for enhancing cardiovascular health in individuals where treatment with exercise is either not possible or undesired. PURPOSE: Compare the effects of exercise and heat training on resistance artery function at rest and during exercise. METHODS: Thirty-five (18 female) healthy, untrained subjects completed a 6-week training program utilizing either high intensity knee extension (KE) exercise (40 min), localized heat therapy (pulsed shortwave diathermy; 120 min), or a sham heat therapy protocol (120 min). We randomly selected 8 subjects from each group to have a temperature probe inserted into their vastus lateralis muscle during one of their training sessions to evaluate the effect of the interventions on muscle temperature. We assessed resistance artery function at rest with the passive leg movement technique (PLM) prior to and after completion of the training protocols. We assessed peak exercise blood flow (KE peak flow) and peak power output (KE peak power) during the KE graded exercise test and prior to and after completion of the training protocols. RESULTS: Peak muscle treatment temperature was significantly different between all groups with those assigned to the diathermy heat training exhibiting a higher peak temperature (~40.80°C) than those in the exercise (~37.75°C, P < 0.001) and sham training groups (~36.10°C, P < 0.001). KE peak flow during PLM increased to the same extent (P = 0.625) in both the exercise (~10.5% increase, P = 0.009) and heating groups (~8.5% increase, P = 0.044); but tended to decrease in the sham group (P = 0.087). KE peak flow increased in the exercise group (~19%, P = 0.005), but did not change in the heat group (P = 0.523) and decreased in the sham group (~7%, P = 0.020). Peak vascular conductance during KE significantly increased by ~25% in the exercise (P = 0.030) and heat (P = 0.012) groups. KE peak power increased in the exercise group by ~27% (P = 0.001) but did not significantly change in the heat (P = 0.175) and sham groups (P = 0.111). The change in vascular function, assessed via PLM, showed a correlation with both ∆KE peak flow (R = 0.55, P = 0.01) and ∆KE peak power (R = 0.56, P = .010). Likewise, ∆KE peak flow showed a strong association with ∆KE peak power (R = 0.64, P < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Localized diathermy heat treatment increased resistance artery function at rest and during exercise to a similar extent as single-leg KE exercise training but did not yield significant improvements in performance. Thus, heat training mimics some but not all of the benefits associated with exercise and may be used to replace exercise treatment to some extent.
College and Department
Life Sciences; Exercise Sciences
BYU ScholarsArchive Citation
Wallace, Taysom Erica, "A Comparison of the Effects of Heat Therapy and Exercise Training on Vascular Function During Passive and Active Exercise" (2021). Theses and Dissertations. 9816.
heat therapy, passive leg movement, exercise blood flow, vascular function, pulsed shortwave diathermy